Acquiring a business can be one of the most rewarding and complex transactions an entrepreneur or investor undertakes. Whether you are expanding your portfolio, entering a new market, or transitioning from employment to ownership, the stakes are high. A misstep in the acquisition process can result in unexpected liabilities, regulatory hurdles, or financial losses.
Smart buyers often consider many of the same issues when buying a business. Below is a brief overview of some issues that can help buyers close their deal, minimize their risks, and set themselves up to succeed. (Legal qualifier: This is by no means a list of every issue or consideration; this is a list of some of the many issues that I have found help clients address their risks and accomplish their goals when they buy a business.)
A well-defined acquisition plan sets the tone for negotiations and decision-making. Buyers should identify their non-negotiables or “red lines” and areas of flexibility. The plan should include timelines, financing options, and contingency strategies. While plans may evolve, having a clear framework helps maintain focus and discipline.
Tip: Prepare a plan that includes a timeline and budget for you to conduct your due diligence and negotiate the transaction. Be prepared to walk away if the deal does not meet your essential criteria. Prepare an alternative or back-up plan if this transaction does not close.
When considering the acquisition of a business, one of the most critical decisions is choosing between an asset purchase and a share purchase. Each structure has distinct legal, financial, and operational implications.
Asset Purchase: In an asset purchase, the buyer selects specific assets to acquire, such as equipment, inventory, contracts, and intellectual property. This approach allows the buyer to avoid assuming the seller’s liabilities, for the most part, offering greater control and risk mitigation. Some liabilities may transfer by operation of law or contract, such as environmental obligations, provincial sales tax (in Saskatchewan), or certain employee-related liabilities. It may also require more third-party consents and complex documentation. However, it may require more third-party consents and complex documentation, as each asset must be individually transferred.
Share Purchase: A share purchase involves acquiring the ownership of the target corporation itself, including all its assets and liabilities. This method is often simpler and may preserve existing contracts and relationships, but it exposes the buyer to historical liabilities and hidden risks.
Potential Liabilities: In a share purchase, the buyer inherits all liabilities, known and unknown, which can include pending litigation, tax obligations, and environmental liabilities. In contrast, an asset purchase allows the buyer to cherry-pick assets and leave behind unwanted liabilities, although some liabilities may still transfer by operation of law.
Third-Party Consents: Both structures may require third-party consents, but asset purchases typically involve more consents due to the need to transfer individual contracts and licenses. Share purchases may require fewer consents, as the corporate entity remains unchanged, but regulatory approvals may still be necessary.
Tip: Consult legal counsel early to determine which structure best aligns with your business goals, risk tolerance, and tax strategy.
The structure through which the acquired business is owned and operated can significantly impact liability exposure, tax efficiency, and long-term flexibility.
Holding Corporations: Using a holding corporation to acquire shares can provide some personal liability protection for shareholders and facilitate tax planning. It allows for the separation of business operations from personal assets, reducing personal risk.
Operating Companies: Incorporating a new operating company to manage acquired assets can streamline operations and provide a clear organizational structure. This approach can also offer tax advantages and facilitate future business expansion or sale.
Family Trusts: Utilizing family trusts can be an effective strategy for tax planning and succession. Trusts can hold ownership interests, providing income-splitting opportunities and facilitating the transfer of wealth to future generations.
Business acquisitions can be structured to include a number of these structures. It is important to consider your options and consult with a lawyer and tax advisor to choose the best business structure for your acquisition.
Tip: Work with both legal and tax advisors to design a business structure that supports your financial objectives and protects your personal assets.
Due diligence is the cornerstone of a successful acquisition, involving a comprehensive investigation of the target business’s legal, financial, operational, and tax affairs.
Legal Due Diligence: This includes reviewing corporate records, contracts, litigation history, regulatory compliance, and intellectual property. The goal is to uncover legal risks and verify asset ownership.
Financial Due Diligence: Analyzing financial statements, tax filings, and cash flow is crucial to assess the business’s financial health and identify any discrepancies or red flags.
Operational Due Diligence: Evaluating the business’s operations, including supply chain, production processes, and customer relationships, helps identify potential operational risks and integration challenges.
Tax Due Diligence: Understanding the target’s tax position, including any outstanding liabilities or disputes, is essential to avoid unexpected tax consequences post-acquisition.
Failing to conduct thorough due diligence can result in acquiring undisclosed liabilities, overpaying for the business, or encountering operational disruptions post-closing.
Tip: Do not rush due diligence. Take the time to request, organize, and critically review all documents provided by the seller. Have your lawyer lead the due diligence process and make sure to include your accountant and tax advisor in the process.
Tax considerations play a pivotal role in determining the net value of the transaction and should be integrated into the acquisition strategy from the outset.
GST/HST and Provincial Taxes: Buyers must understand the implications of GST/HST and provincial taxes on the transaction, including any exemptions or rebates that may apply.
Capital Gains: The choice between an asset and share purchase affects capital gains treatment. Asset purchases may allow for the step-up of asset bases (i.e., ability to revalue assets for depreciation/capital gains purposes), potentially reducing future capital gains tax.
The transaction structure influences tax outcomes, with asset purchases often providing more opportunities for tax planning, such as asset depreciation and amortization.
Tip: Include tax planning as a core part of your acquisition strategy and not as an afterthought.
Accurate valuation is critical to negotiating a fair purchase price and ensuring the acquisition aligns with the buyer’s financial objectives.
EBITDA Multiples: This method assesses profitability by comparing the target’s earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization to industry benchmarks. It is commonly used for businesses with stable cash flows.
Asset-Based Valuation: This approach values the business based on the fair market value of its tangible and intangible assets. It is particularly useful for asset-heavy businesses or those with significant intellectual property.
Market Comparables: Comparing the target to similar businesses that have been sold recently can provide a benchmark for valuation. This method considers market trends and industry conditions.
A professional valuation supports negotiations by providing an objective basis for the purchase price, helping to prevent overpayment, and ensuring the buyer’s interests are protected. Each valuation method has limits. A professional analysis and sound business judgment is critical.
Also, note that it is common for the purchase price to be adjusted post-closing through mechanisms like escrows, holdbacks, or earnout clauses, which protect the buyer by ensuring that specific financial targets or conditions are met before the full price is paid. Details are negotiated as part of the purchase and sale agreement. These options provide a safeguard for buyers against potential discrepancies in the business’s performance or asset valuation, allowing for a more accurate reflection of the business’s worth.
Tip: Do not rely solely on the seller’s asking price. Conduct your own independent valuation, consult with your advisors, and be prepared to negotiate (or have your lawyer) negotiate the purchase price.
The financing structure of the acquisition affects cash flow, control, and risk exposure. A business can be purchased using a combination of the following options.
Debt Financing: Borrowing from banks or private lenders can provide the necessary capital while allowing the buyer to retain full ownership. However, it increases financial risk and requires regular repayments.
Equity Financing: Raising capital from investors or partners can reduce financial risk and provide additional resources for growth. However, it may dilute ownership and control.
Seller Financing: In this arrangement, the seller provides a loan or retains an interest in the business, facilitating the transaction. It can align the seller’s interests with the buyer’s success but may complicate the deal structure.
Each financing option has different implications for cash flow management and control over the business. It is essential to choose a structure that balances affordability with long-term sustainability. Remember that lender-imposed covenants can significantly impact operational flexibility, as they may restrict certain business activities, such as taking on additional debt or making large capital expenditures and require adherence to specific financial metrics. These covenants can limit the company’s ability to respond to market opportunities or challenges, potentially affecting growth and strategic decision-making.
Tip: Choose a financing structure that balances affordability with long-term sustainability. Work with your advisors in selecting your financing structure early on in the process.
Beyond financials, buyers must verify the ownership and condition of all business assets. This includes real property, equipment, inventory, and digital assets such as domain names and software licenses. Intellectual property (trademarks, patents, copyrights) should be carefully reviewed to ensure proper registration and transferability. Any encumbrances, such as liens or disputes, must be resolved before closing. It is possible to negotiate with the seller so that some encumbrances are assumed, paid off, or addressed prior to closing, in either an asset or share purchase.
Tip: Include a rigorous review of assets and property in your due diligence and ensure any risks or liabilities are reflected in the purchase price and in the definitive transaction documents.
Employees are a critical component of any business, and employment-related liabilities can be substantial. Buyers should review employment contracts, compensation structures, and workplace policies. It is also important to understand obligations under provincial labour laws and statutory requirements, including termination rights, severance entitlements, and union agreements. Failure to address these issues can lead to disputes and financial exposure post-acquisition.
Tip: Do not assume employment obligations transfer automatically. Review them in detail with legal counsel.
Environmental risks can be significant, particularly in industries such as manufacturing, agriculture, or resource extraction. Buyers should conduct environmental assessments and review compliance with federal and provincial regulations. Historical contamination, hazardous materials, and non-compliance can result in fines, cleanup costs, and reputational damage; this can be an issue even if the buyer was unaware and even after the transaction closes. Also, environmental liabilities can bind the owners of the property as well as the directors of corporations that own the contaminated land in question.
Tip: If the business owns or leases industrial property, environmental due diligence is essential. Ask the seller for any environmental studies, and if no recent studies are available, you should consider taking the time and spending the money to obtain a Phase I and/or Phase II environmental assessment.
In today’s digital economy, data protection is a critical concern. If the business collects or processes personal data, buyers must ensure compliance with Canadian privacy laws. This includes reviewing data handling practices, consent mechanisms, and cybersecurity protocols. Non-compliance can lead to regulatory penalties and loss of customer trust.
Tip: Ask whether the business has ever experienced a data breach and how it was handled.
For small or medium-sized private companies, obtaining third-party consents is a crucial step in the acquisition process. These consents are often required for key contracts, such as leases, supplier agreements, and customer contracts, which may contain change-of-control provisions. Failure to secure these consents can disrupt business operations and diminish the value of the acquisition. It is essential to identify all contracts that require consent early in the due diligence process and assess the potential impact of any delays or denials. Securing consents, where required for the transfer or assignment of contracts or for contracts that have change of control clauses, help maintain business continuity and protects the overall value of the transaction.
Tip: Do not assume contracts are transferable. Verify and obtain written consents where necessary. Begin identifying critical contracts and consents during the due diligence phase.
The value of a business often lies in its relationships. Buyers should assess the customer base for loyalty, concentration risk, and revenue stability. Vendor contracts should be reviewed for pricing terms, exclusivity clauses, and termination rights. These relationships may not be easily transferable, and their loss can materially affect the business.
Tip: Meet key customers and vendors before closing to gauge their commitment to the new ownership. Consider obtaining written agreements in advance of closing to retain key employees or contracts, and even customers.
Successful post-closing integration is crucial to realizing the full value of the acquisition. Transitioning leadership roles and responsibilities is often necessary to align the acquired business with the buyer’s strategic vision. Clear communication and planning are essential to minimize disruption. Retaining key employees is critical to maintaining operational continuity and preserving institutional knowledge. Offering incentives and fostering a positive work environment can aid retention efforts. Plus, ensuring seamless integration of systems, processes, and cultures is vital to achieving operational continuity. Developing a detailed integration plan before closing can help address potential challenges.
Effective integration strategies include establishing clear goals, maintaining open communication, and monitoring progress regularly. These efforts can help ensure a smooth transition and maximize the acquisition’s value.
Tip: Start integration planning before the deal closes.
Professional advisors are essential throughout the acquisition process. A lawyer can advise on transaction structure, negotiate contracts, and manage due diligence. An accountant can assess financial health, tax implications, and valuation. A tax advisor can advise on the tax implications and risks of the transaction and help through the due diligence phase. Together, they help protect your interests and ensure the deal is legally and financially sound.
Tip: Choose a lawyer, accountant, and tax advisor with specific experience in business acquisitions.
Buying a business is a complex and high-stakes endeavor. Success depends not only on identifying the right opportunity but also on executing the transaction with precision and foresight. By understanding the legal, financial, and operational dimensions of the acquisition, and by working closely with experienced advisors, you can avoid costly mistakes and position yourself for long-term success.
Disclaimer. This information is general and may not apply to your specific situation. Always consult a qualified lawyer and tax advisor before making business decisions.
#BusinessAcquisition #BuyingABusiness #MergersAndAcquisitions #CorporateLaw #DueDiligence #BusinessLaw #DealStructuring #TaxPlanning #BusinessValuation #PrivateEquity #Entrepreneurship #BusinessStrategy #SmallBusiness #LegalInsights #Business #Investment #SmallBusinessTips #DealMaking